|previous article in this issue||next article in this issue|
Document Details :
Title: The Complementary Faces of Mathematical Beauty
Author(s): VAN BENDEGEM, Jean Paul , DESMET, Ronny
Journal: Logique et Analyse
Volume: 237 Date: 2017
This article focuses on the writings of Hardy, Poincaré, Birkhoff, and Whitehead, in order to substantiate the claim that mathematicians experience a mathematical proof as beautiful when it offers a maximum of insight while demanding a minimum of effort. In other words, it claims that the study of the aesthetic success of theorem-proofs can benefit from the analogy with the economic success of a business, which involves maximizing return on investment. On the other hand, the article also draws on Le Lionnais and Whitehead (again) in order to show that, whereas the kind of aesthetic delight offered by beautiful proofs is typical for well-established branches of mathematics, a romantic and adventurous spirit that goes beyond the search for classical aesthetic delights is needed when the exploration of new mathematics is at stake. The history of mathematics is not only a story of feelings of beauty invoked by perfect products, but also a survey of sublime periods of creative production. No account of mathematical beauty can be complete if it does not complement the classical product aesthetics with a romantic creation aesthetics.