this issue
previous article in this issuenext article in this issue

Document Details :

Title: Not a Modest Proposal
Subtitle: Peter Singer and the Definition of Person
Author(s): HYMERS, John
Journal: Ethical Perspectives
Volume: 6    Issue: 2   Date: 1999   
Pages: 126-138
DOI: 10.2143/EP.6.2.505351

Abstract :
In this paper I take issue with Singer's use of the distinction between the person and the human. In so doing, I first explain Singer's basic position on personhood and sentience, and the relative value of organisms named under these two terms. With this discussion in hand, I then lay stress on a simple and repeated dictum of Singer's: the newborn infant up to the age of one month is not a person. This leads us to the position that the only possible ground for the selective infanticide of disabled infants is that newborn infants, healthy or not, are not persons, primarily because they lack self-consciousness. Then I investigate his ideas of personhood and selfconsciousness as abstractions. Finally, in conclusion, I offer some observations drawn from Jonathan Swift.

Download article