this issue
previous article in this issuenext article in this issue

Document Details :

Title: A Tale of Two Pyres
Subtitle: Re-evaluating the Bogomil Trial Scene of Anna Komnene
Author(s): MINCIN, Elisabeth
Journal: Byzantion
Volume: 89    Date: 2019   
Pages: 421-432
DOI: 10.2143/BYZ.89.0.3287078

Abstract :
This article concerns the trial sequence narrated by Anna Komnene in Book XV section 9.2-5 of her Alexiad. In this passage, the princess historian describes a dramatic show trial in which a large number of accused Bogomils are brought together and given the choice between two pyres – one representing repentance to Orthodoxy whilst the other representing the maintenance of their heretical beliefs. In either case, they were all to be sentenced to death. I argue that this scene is not simply theatrical but, in fact, a complete fiction, engineered by Anna for the sake of enforcing a desired ideological image of her father as a Christ-like saviour.

Download article