next article in this issue  |
|
Document Details : Title: Alle gekheid in een hokje Subtitle: Over de wortels van het psychiatrisch essentialisme Author(s): ADRIAENS, Pieter R. , DE BLOCK, Andreas Journal: Tijdschrift voor Filosofie Volume: 72 Issue: 1 Date: 2010 Pages: 7-39 DOI: 10.2143/TVF.72.1.2047016 Abstract : Psychiatry tends to make order out of disorder. Although mental disorders are not natural kinds, many psychiatrists still conceive of mental disorders as discrete entities with a distinct and primarily biological etiology. To a certain extent, such psychiatric essentialism is shared by lay people as well. In this paper, we explicate what the natural kind view of mental disorders amounts to, and why it is implausible. Most importantly, however, we spell out a number of factors that account for the success of the natural kind view in scientific and popular thinking, despite its being ontologically flawed. Building upon recently developed theories about ‘folk biology’ and ‘psychological essentialism’, we argue that different historical processes have homogenized psychiatric populations, thereby making these populations prone to trigger the folk biology module and its essentializing mechanisms. |
|
